“The world seems to be collapsing, the humanities are in crisis, but in this uncertain-at-best moment, Sarah Mesle offers writers a path not just toward hope but toward joy, as well. In this immensely readable, immensely useful book, Mesle reminds us why it remains worthwhile to sit down and put words to paper.”
— Naomi Fry, staff writer, The New Yorker
“Fresh, nerdy, sober, quirky, and only sort of optimistic, Reasons and Feelings wrestles with the angle that could make writing better—or even simply possible—as the humanities totter around us.”
— William Germano, author of "On Revision"
“With Reasons and Feelings, Mesle has given us a guide for the perplexed—for those who aren’t sure what intellectual life in the humanities will look like tomorrow, let alone several years from now; for those who aren’t certain how, why, or where to write about the books and ideas that matter to them; which is to say, for all of us. Writing as ally, therapist, expert, veteran, teacher, colleague, storyteller, and host, Mesle gives us a pioneer’s and survivor’s view of humanistic writing after the coming-apart of postwar structures and tells us that we’re not alone, that we’re (still) in this together.”
— Nicholas Dames, coeditor in chief of Public Books
"Mesle’s book (and certainly her own career as exemplar) demonstrates what it takes and what it means to be an academic humanist now: the thinning crossdisciplinarity, the disparate writing an academic does and what crossing genre boundaries look like. . . . it’s a book working to avail itself of a different style of the 'guide to writing' genre to attempt to know the world differently. It succeeds at that, in spades."
— Massachusetts Review