ABOUT THIS BOOK

A collaboration between three distinguished professors of linguistics and philosophy.

The result of the collaboration between three distinguished philosophers, this book comprises the best sample of one of the most original theories in contemporary philosophy of language and communication—Critical Pragmatics. They present the development of the theory from its initial sprout, with “Three Demonstrations and a Funeral” (2006) as its first visible result, to a critical clarification of its tenets in “Critical Pragmatics: Nine Misconceptions” (2023). After Korta and Perry’s Critical Pragmatics (2011), this is the most important book on Critical Pragmatics, as it was conceived, developed and applied by its creators. Having de Ponte, Korta and Perry’s most important papers together on one place will be of great value to both philosophers and linguists.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Maria de Ponte is associate professor at the University of the Basque Country and director of the Institute for Logic, Cognition, Language and Information. Kepa Korta is a philosopher of language at the Institute for Logic, Cognition, Language and Information of the University of the Basque Country. John Perry is the Henry Waldgrave Stuart Professor of Philosophy emeritus at Stanford University.

REVIEWS

It is wonderful to have all seventeen of these papers (previously dispersed across myriad journals and books) together in a single volume, amply demonstrating the explanatory power and depth of the Critical Pragmatics paradigm. The volume will be an indispensable reference for anyone wanting to understand how linguistic communication works.

— Robyn Carston (University College London)

María de Ponte, Kepa Korta and John Perry’s Three Demonstrations and a Funeral and other Essays does not just bring together a set of individually important contributions to issues at the intersection of semantics and pragmatics. Taken together, the papers offer a compelling picture of what we say and do with our utterances, thereby demonstrating the fruitfulness of the theoretical framework originating in Perry's Reference and Reflexivity (2001). It should be read by any philosophers interested in language, mind and action.

— Stacie Friend (University of Edinburgh)

The papers in this volume sharpen Critical Pragmatics, focusing critically on approaches that postulate some form of pragmatic intrusion, and expand it, applying it to a variety of issues, including fictional names, the passage of time, Frege’s notion of identity and the notion of luck. The last paper contains an extremely well-articulated defense of the theory from a series of pervasive (and incomprehensible, one might add) misconceptions.

Having all these papers in a single volume will be an inestimable tool for anyone interested in critical pragmatics and, more generally, for anyone interested in reference, communication, and the semantics and pragmatics of referential devices.

— Genoveva Martí (University of Barcelona)

Started with the collaboration between John Perry and Kepa Korta, this kaleidoscopic selection of papers is enriched in its last part with the intrusion of a third element, María de Ponte, who brings new subjects into focus, such as the topic of luck and of fictional entities. Most of the papers mix a high analytic endeavor with the levity of multifarious examples that help clarify the most irksome conceptual points. Even the old fashioned Fregean themes find a new illumination, following the idea that the late Frege’s suggestion to consider truth values as the referent of a sentence obliged many philosophers to make a long detour to reach a new interpretation of what he suggested in the introduction of his Ideography. And, eventually, readers will find, not so hidden inside the selection of papers, new insight on the original topic from which all started: the essential demonstratives.

— Carlo Penco (University of Genoa)

John Perry’s reflexive-referential theory, as expounded (inter alia) in his masterpiece Reference and Reflexivity, applies tools from action theory to issues in the philosophy of language and communication. Pragmatics as a discipline evolved from a new conception of language as action put forward by philosophers such as John Austin, Paul Grice and Peter Strawson (not to mention Wittgenstein). The affinities between these different approaches are obvious and open up an interesting research program: explore the potential of Perry’s reflexive-referential theory to illuminate and hopefully resolve pending issues in pragmatics. Carrying out this research program was the aim of Korta’s and Perry’s first joint book, Critical Pragmatics, and it remains the aim of this major collection of papers where de Ponte, Korta and Perry attempt to arbitrate the current debates on the semantics/pragmatics distinction, the minimalism/contextualism debate, etc. The book offers new insights on key issues and is a must read for philosophers and linguists working in that area.

— François Recanati (Collége de France)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. Three Demonstrations and A Funeral 1
KORTA AND PERRY

2 Radical Minimalism, Moderate Contextualism 25
KORTA AND PERRY

3 How to Say Things with Words 43
KORTA AND PERRY

4 The Pragmatic Circle 63
KORTA AND PERRY

5 Reference: A New Paradigm 75
KORTA AND PERRY

6 Intentions to Refer 87
KORTA AND PERRY

7 What is Said 107
KORTA AND PERRY

8 Highlights of Critical Pragmatics: Reference and the Contents of the
Utterance 123
KORTA AND PERRY

9 Squaring the Circle 143
KORTA AND PERRY

10 Full but not Saturated: The Myth of Mandatory Primary Pragmatic
Processes 155
KORTA AND PERRY

11 New Thoughts about Old Facts: On Prior’s Root Canal 173
DE PONTE AND KORTA

12 Truth without Reference: The Use of Fictional Names 191
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

13 Utterance and Context 211
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

14 Four Puzzling Paragraphs. Frege on “=” and “=” 225
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

15 Language and Luck 245
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

16 Philosophy of Language and Action Theory 265
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

17 Critical Pragmatics: Nine Misconceptions 287
DE PONTE, KORTA AND PERRY

References 307
Index 319