“The most stirring and lucid account of World War II that I have ever read.”
— Joseph Heller
“Anytime he writes of war you can smell the gunsmoke. A book like this was needed to remind us what it was like. . . . A remarkable achievement.”
— James Michener
“[Jones] overcomes the vastness of the event by emphasizing his personal experience of it, thus giving the reader a foothold in the text that is far more satisfying than gliding across a glossy overview. He overcomes his limited viewpoint of the war by symbolizing it in the experience of the common infantryman and locating in that experience a unique significance.”
— Christopher Lehmann-Haupt, New York Times
“A remarkable history. . . .This was a substantial effort—[Jones] had both the long view and the personal one, having not only experienced the war but having thought long and hard about it.”
— Robert Gottlieb, New York Review of Books
“Jones is a man of experience and memories. . . . [He] has written WWII with passion, projected in accounts of actions he never saw no less than of actions in which he participated. . . . Anyone can salute WWII as providing vivid vicarious experiences, a mind-bending extension into new territory of whatever one knew before, not only about war but about human nature.”
— Alfred C. Ames, Chicago Tribune
“An expert, eloquent personal remembrance of battles past, what it felt like to live each day as possibly one’s last, what it felt like to go into battle, and finally what it felt like to get hit. . . written by one of the best combat novelists of our time.”
— San Francisco Examiner & Chronicle
“Spectacular and revealing.”
— National Observer
“Amazing . . . . With his inimitable bent for realism, his perception and his combat infantry experiences in the South Pacific, [Jones] has managed to write about the whole war, in all its far-flung theaters, and with its entire cast of combatants. . . . . Should be required reading.”
— Cleveland Press
“Combat, as it appeared to the GIs who dodged bullets and watched their comrades die, is brilliantly portrayed . . . . An antidote to the hundreds of books about the war which have been written by generals and politicians.”
— New York Daily News
“Anyone who truly wants to understand [our] civilization ought to read it.”
— Providence Journal
“Superb. . . the sights, the sounds and smells of the war as well as the feelings of the men who fought it. . . . WWII will bring the memories flooding back; for the student of that global conflict and for the general reader . . . a vivid, highly instructive capsule course in what happened during those dramatic 44-plus months.”
— Philadelphia Bulletin
“This may be Jones’s great contribution to the history of war.”
— New Haven Register
“This account is brutally honest, scathingly critical and even funny at times. Jones’s vivid, vulnerable memoir cuts through a veil of nostalgia that often surrounds the war. Instances of horror and levity punctuate his evolution as a soldier and the eventual begrudging acceptance of his own insignificant role in the American war machine. He also fiercely condemns the wasting of lives by careless or politically motivated strategists. Jones’s insightful mix of memoir and military history is engrossing.”
— Shelf Awareness
“Jones does some remarkably sharp reflecting on the art and practice of history-writing itself—this is an entirely, refreshingly earnest book for all its gruff jadedness. . . . ‘In my old age I have about come to believe that the whole of written history is miscreated and flawed by these discrepancies in the two ideals systems,’ Jones (who was 52 at the time) writes, ‘the one of how we would all like to believe humanity to be, but only the privileged can afford to believe is; and the one of how we all really know humanity in fact is, but none of us wants to believe it.’ In a way that’s both slightly ironic and slightly saddening, Jones’ book manages to proceed equally in both those systems simultaneously, and the end effect, mesmerizing in its own way, is that of a smart, hot-hearted man trying to grapple with the epic thing that happened to him in his youth. Jones died far too young, only a couple of years after he wrote this book, and it’s a powerful, curious testimony. The good folks at University of Chicago Press are to be congratulated for salvaging it and putting it in front of the bookshopping crowds this winter.”
— Steve Donoghue, Open Letters Monthly
“A classic of its type. . . . Many eerie details . . . make [Jones’s] chronicle ring with authenticity, such as the look on the face of the wounded who have ‘entered some realm where the others, the unwounded, cannot follow.’ . . . The Pacific and Europe, war art, the home front and much more are depicted with memorable immediacy.”
— Steven Carroll, The Age (Australia)
“A unique and fascinating volume. Even now, after a perpetually surging Noah’s flood of ‘Good War’ literature, WWII stands out as one of the most vivid documents ever produced on how the war looked and felt to those who experienced it firsthand. . . . A too-little-known piece of work by a great American writer, and readers will discover unexpected, alarming, dazzling or horrifying observations on every page.”
— Lee Sandlin, Wall Street Journal