The Powell Expedition: New Discoveries about John Wesley Powell's 1869 River Journey
by Don Lago
University of Nevada Press, 2017 Paper: 978-1-948908-20-7 | Cloth: 978-1-943859-43-6 | eISBN: 978-0-87417-599-8 Library of Congress Classification F788.L3373 2017 Dewey Decimal Classification 979.13
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
"The Powell Expedition is a thought-provoking, nuanced work that reads at times like a detective story, and it should offer much fodder for historians."
—TheWall Street Journal
John Wesley Powell’s 1869 expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers and through the Grand Canyon continues to be one of the most celebrated adventures in American history, ranking with the Lewis and Clark expedition and the Apollo landings on the moon. For nearly twenty years Lago has researched the Powell expedition from new angles, traveled to thirteen states, and looked into archives and other sources no one else has searched. He has come up with many important new documents that change and expand our basic understanding of the expedition by looking into Powell’s crewmembers, some of whom have been almost entirely ignored by Powell historians. Historians tended to assume that Powell was the whole story and that his crewmembers were irrelevant. More seriously, because several crew members made critical comments about Powell and his leadership, historians who admired Powell were eager to ignore and discredit them.
Lago offers a feast of new and important material about the river trip, and it will significantly rewrite the story of Powell’s famous expedition. This book is not only a major work on the Powell expedition, but on the history of American exploration of the West.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Don Lago is one of the most respected historians of the Grand Canyon, and the author of Grand Canyon: A History of a Natural Wonder and National Park. He has published more than 50 personal essays in national magazines and literary journals. His latest book is Where the Sky Touched the Earth: Cosmological Landscapes of the Southwest. He lives in Flagstaff, Arizona.
REVIEWS
"The Powell Expedition is a thought-provoking, nuanced work that reads at times like a detective story, and it should offer much fodder for historians."
— The Wall Street Journal
"Lago examines many theories about the fate of three members of Powell’s expedition who left the river before the end of the journey and were never seen again. While the true fate of these explorers may never be known, there are enough leads in this account to entertain Colorado River rafters around campfires for years. Grand Canyon enthusiasts will find much to consider in this book."
— Library Journal
"This is no straightforward river adventure, but rather a collection of multiple intriguing theories about various disputed facts, making for excellent campfire stories after a long day on the river."
— Publisher's Weekly
"Lago is a storyteller, and his accessible, sprightly writing style makes what could be a mind-numbing collection of facts read like an adventure yarn."
— New York Journal of Books
"Written in a refreshingly transparent first-person style, Lago demythologizes Powell, corrects past libels and properly puts the focus on his crew. This book will be of interest to historians and river rats alike."
— True West Magazine
"Lago’s latest book is the result of 20 years of research across 13 states, digging into the history of the expedition’s individual crew members to tell a far more specific story that the broad tale of river running and canyon mapping.”
— Grand Canyon News
"Conjecture (readily admitted) and tangential wanderings pervade the text, resting comfortably alongside nuggets of deep research that rewrite important aspects of Powell's story and offer insight on Western exploration."
— Roundup Magazine
"Don Lago’s The Powell Expedition: New Discoveries about John Wesley Powell’s 1869 River Journeytakes a new, fresh look at the 1869 expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers led by John Wesley Powell. He concentrates especially on the often-overlooked members of the crew, and the events that led to distrust, tension, and the eventual departure of three members of the party, as well as an in-depth look at the deaths of those three and the subsequent lives of most, if not all, of the men. The book is definitely a significant and novel contribution to the literature on Powell, and that’s saying something. The sources Lago consulted are astounding, in a word.”
— Roy Webb, author of Riverman: The Story of Bus Hat
“Don Lago has spent over 20 years researching Powell’s 1869 river expedition, ferreting out details nobody else has discovered, myth-busting, speculating, and clarifying the whys and wherefores of the trip. This book is a culmination of those details and speculation, with updates on his previous writings and adding a wealth of new material. Lago covers topics no other Powell biographer/author has addressed, or ones in this depth.”
— Richard Quartaroli, special collections librarian emeritus, Northern Arizona University
"In search of answers and explanations, he delves into details of chronologies, genealogies, and politics, but he keeps the stories alive by following out speculations and connections along unexpected trails of evidence... Offering many intriguing new ideas and directions for further research, Lago's The Powell Expedition will be of great interest to scholars of Powell's survey. For anyone with an interest in Colorado River history, Lago's book will be enjoyable reading."
— The Western Historical Quarterly
"Anniversaries of key historical events spawn books, and the 150th anniversary of John Wesley Powell's 1869 exploration of the Green and Colorado Rivers has bred several. The best of these so far is Don Lago's The Powell Expedition. The most revered writers on the topic tend to be either academics or rivers guides, erstwhile or present. Academics bring the best tools of their disciplines to the subject, while river guides bring their understanding of the river. Lago, a respected Grand Canyon historian, brings both...he manages to do what office-bound writers find difficult: give the reader a sense of what it is like to be on the river at night, jawing with longtime guides steeped in the sources who love to explore mysteries that have no definitive answers. If you are serious about understanding Powell's first expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers, this is the book to read during this sesquicentennial year."
— Utah Historical Quarterly
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents
Introduction ix
Prologue: Dreams of Rivers 3
Part I: The James White Mystery
1. Introduction to the James White Mystery 21
2. WANTED - James White 27
3. An Old Story 36
4. Rivals and Rails 45
5. Dawson and Teller 57
6. Conclusion? 65
Part II: The Crew
7. The Howland Connection 69
8. Seneca Howland: The Unsung Hero 81
9. Call Me No Name 90
10. The Howland Brothers Write Home 100
11. What's Eating the Howland Brothers? 111
12. The Curse of Howland Island 121
13. Introducing William H. Dunn 126
14. Last Words Before the Launch 138
15. William Hawkins: Abducted by Alias! 144
16. The Promotion of Andy Hall 158
17. The Westering Star of Jack Sumner 168
18. Why Jack Sumner Stayed 178
19. The Madness of Jack Sumner 190
20. Jack Sumner Looks Back 196
Part III: John Wesley Powell
21. Horse Feathers 203
22. Major Powell, I Presume 208
23. The Impeachment of John Wesley Powell 217
Part IV: Naming Names
24. The Maid of the Cañon 235
25. Lodore 245
Part V: The End of the Adventure
26. Hats Off to Bishop Leithead 257
27. A Hardy Welcome 261
28. The Afterlife of a Boat 265
Part VI: The Fate of the Howland Brothers and William Dunn
29. Introduction 273
30. Toab 281
31. The Toquerville Hoax 292
32. Three Men Sentenced to Be Shot 299
33. The Aftermath 320
34. The Arizona Strip Massacre 336
35. The Afterlife of William Hawkins 340
36. Conclusion? 361
Afterword: Ten Who Bored 363
Bibliography 371
Acknowledgments 383
About the Author 386
Index 387
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
The Powell Expedition: New Discoveries about John Wesley Powell's 1869 River Journey
by Don Lago
University of Nevada Press, 2017 Paper: 978-1-948908-20-7 Cloth: 978-1-943859-43-6 eISBN: 978-0-87417-599-8
"The Powell Expedition is a thought-provoking, nuanced work that reads at times like a detective story, and it should offer much fodder for historians."
—TheWall Street Journal
John Wesley Powell’s 1869 expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers and through the Grand Canyon continues to be one of the most celebrated adventures in American history, ranking with the Lewis and Clark expedition and the Apollo landings on the moon. For nearly twenty years Lago has researched the Powell expedition from new angles, traveled to thirteen states, and looked into archives and other sources no one else has searched. He has come up with many important new documents that change and expand our basic understanding of the expedition by looking into Powell’s crewmembers, some of whom have been almost entirely ignored by Powell historians. Historians tended to assume that Powell was the whole story and that his crewmembers were irrelevant. More seriously, because several crew members made critical comments about Powell and his leadership, historians who admired Powell were eager to ignore and discredit them.
Lago offers a feast of new and important material about the river trip, and it will significantly rewrite the story of Powell’s famous expedition. This book is not only a major work on the Powell expedition, but on the history of American exploration of the West.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Don Lago is one of the most respected historians of the Grand Canyon, and the author of Grand Canyon: A History of a Natural Wonder and National Park. He has published more than 50 personal essays in national magazines and literary journals. His latest book is Where the Sky Touched the Earth: Cosmological Landscapes of the Southwest. He lives in Flagstaff, Arizona.
REVIEWS
"The Powell Expedition is a thought-provoking, nuanced work that reads at times like a detective story, and it should offer much fodder for historians."
— The Wall Street Journal
"Lago examines many theories about the fate of three members of Powell’s expedition who left the river before the end of the journey and were never seen again. While the true fate of these explorers may never be known, there are enough leads in this account to entertain Colorado River rafters around campfires for years. Grand Canyon enthusiasts will find much to consider in this book."
— Library Journal
"This is no straightforward river adventure, but rather a collection of multiple intriguing theories about various disputed facts, making for excellent campfire stories after a long day on the river."
— Publisher's Weekly
"Lago is a storyteller, and his accessible, sprightly writing style makes what could be a mind-numbing collection of facts read like an adventure yarn."
— New York Journal of Books
"Written in a refreshingly transparent first-person style, Lago demythologizes Powell, corrects past libels and properly puts the focus on his crew. This book will be of interest to historians and river rats alike."
— True West Magazine
"Lago’s latest book is the result of 20 years of research across 13 states, digging into the history of the expedition’s individual crew members to tell a far more specific story that the broad tale of river running and canyon mapping.”
— Grand Canyon News
"Conjecture (readily admitted) and tangential wanderings pervade the text, resting comfortably alongside nuggets of deep research that rewrite important aspects of Powell's story and offer insight on Western exploration."
— Roundup Magazine
"Don Lago’s The Powell Expedition: New Discoveries about John Wesley Powell’s 1869 River Journeytakes a new, fresh look at the 1869 expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers led by John Wesley Powell. He concentrates especially on the often-overlooked members of the crew, and the events that led to distrust, tension, and the eventual departure of three members of the party, as well as an in-depth look at the deaths of those three and the subsequent lives of most, if not all, of the men. The book is definitely a significant and novel contribution to the literature on Powell, and that’s saying something. The sources Lago consulted are astounding, in a word.”
— Roy Webb, author of Riverman: The Story of Bus Hat
“Don Lago has spent over 20 years researching Powell’s 1869 river expedition, ferreting out details nobody else has discovered, myth-busting, speculating, and clarifying the whys and wherefores of the trip. This book is a culmination of those details and speculation, with updates on his previous writings and adding a wealth of new material. Lago covers topics no other Powell biographer/author has addressed, or ones in this depth.”
— Richard Quartaroli, special collections librarian emeritus, Northern Arizona University
"In search of answers and explanations, he delves into details of chronologies, genealogies, and politics, but he keeps the stories alive by following out speculations and connections along unexpected trails of evidence... Offering many intriguing new ideas and directions for further research, Lago's The Powell Expedition will be of great interest to scholars of Powell's survey. For anyone with an interest in Colorado River history, Lago's book will be enjoyable reading."
— The Western Historical Quarterly
"Anniversaries of key historical events spawn books, and the 150th anniversary of John Wesley Powell's 1869 exploration of the Green and Colorado Rivers has bred several. The best of these so far is Don Lago's The Powell Expedition. The most revered writers on the topic tend to be either academics or rivers guides, erstwhile or present. Academics bring the best tools of their disciplines to the subject, while river guides bring their understanding of the river. Lago, a respected Grand Canyon historian, brings both...he manages to do what office-bound writers find difficult: give the reader a sense of what it is like to be on the river at night, jawing with longtime guides steeped in the sources who love to explore mysteries that have no definitive answers. If you are serious about understanding Powell's first expedition down the Green and Colorado Rivers, this is the book to read during this sesquicentennial year."
— Utah Historical Quarterly
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents
Introduction ix
Prologue: Dreams of Rivers 3
Part I: The James White Mystery
1. Introduction to the James White Mystery 21
2. WANTED - James White 27
3. An Old Story 36
4. Rivals and Rails 45
5. Dawson and Teller 57
6. Conclusion? 65
Part II: The Crew
7. The Howland Connection 69
8. Seneca Howland: The Unsung Hero 81
9. Call Me No Name 90
10. The Howland Brothers Write Home 100
11. What's Eating the Howland Brothers? 111
12. The Curse of Howland Island 121
13. Introducing William H. Dunn 126
14. Last Words Before the Launch 138
15. William Hawkins: Abducted by Alias! 144
16. The Promotion of Andy Hall 158
17. The Westering Star of Jack Sumner 168
18. Why Jack Sumner Stayed 178
19. The Madness of Jack Sumner 190
20. Jack Sumner Looks Back 196
Part III: John Wesley Powell
21. Horse Feathers 203
22. Major Powell, I Presume 208
23. The Impeachment of John Wesley Powell 217
Part IV: Naming Names
24. The Maid of the Cañon 235
25. Lodore 245
Part V: The End of the Adventure
26. Hats Off to Bishop Leithead 257
27. A Hardy Welcome 261
28. The Afterlife of a Boat 265
Part VI: The Fate of the Howland Brothers and William Dunn
29. Introduction 273
30. Toab 281
31. The Toquerville Hoax 292
32. Three Men Sentenced to Be Shot 299
33. The Aftermath 320
34. The Arizona Strip Massacre 336
35. The Afterlife of William Hawkins 340
36. Conclusion? 361
Afterword: Ten Who Bored 363
Bibliography 371
Acknowledgments 383
About the Author 386
Index 387
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE